Question 1

What does 1 Samuel 28:11 mean?

Accepted Answer

1 Samuel 28:11 describes the moment when the woman at Endor, a medium, asks Saul whom he wants her to summon from the dead, and Saul replies that he wants her to bring up Samuel. This verse shows Saul directly requesting contact with the deceased prophet Samuel through the woman’s supposed ability. In this scene, Saul, desperate for guidance, visits a woman known for communicating with the dead, even though he had previously banned such practices. The woman, cautious at first, asks Saul for the specific person he wants to reach. Saul’s answer reveals his deep need for Samuel’s wisdom, highlighting the seriousness of his situation and his willingness to break his own laws.

Question 2

The Hebrew behind 1 Samuel 28:11

Accepted Answer

אִשָּׁה (ishah, “woman”): This word emphasizes that the person Saul consults is a woman, which is notable since mediums in ancient Israel were often female and seen as outsiders. עָלָה (alah, “bring up”): This verb is used twice in the verse and means “to go up” or “to bring up.” Here, it refers to the act of summoning someone from the realm of the dead, reflecting the ancient belief that the dead resided “below” the living. שְׁמוּאֵל (Shemu’el, “Samuel”): Saul specifically names Samuel, showing he is not seeking just any answer, but the guidance of the prophet who had once led and advised him.

Question 3

Why 1 Samuel 28:11 matters

Accepted Answer

This verse clarifies that Saul is the one initiating the request to contact Samuel, not the woman, which shows his personal responsibility in seeking forbidden spiritual guidance. The use of the word “bring up” twice highlights the ancient view of the afterlife and the seriousness of Saul’s request to disturb someone from the dead. The verse connects to the wider story by showing Saul’s desperation and the lengths he is willing to go after God no longer answers him through accepted means.

1 Samuel 28:11 (KJV)