Question 1

What does John 20:23 mean?

Accepted Answer

John 20:23 describes Jesus telling his disciples that if they forgive anyone’s sins, those sins are forgiven, and if they withhold forgiveness, those sins are not forgiven. This verse shows Jesus giving his followers a special responsibility related to forgiveness after his resurrection. In this scene, the risen Jesus is speaking directly to his disciples in a locked room, just after appearing to them. The verse follows Jesus breathing on them and saying, “Receive ye the Holy Ghost,” which connects this authority to the Spirit’s work. The statement is often understood as Jesus entrusting his followers with the message and ministry of forgiveness, not as a personal power, but as representatives sharing God’s forgiveness.

Question 2

The Greek behind John 20:23

Accepted Answer

ἀφίημι (aphiēmi, “remit” or “forgive”): This word means to send away, release, or forgive. In this context, it emphasizes the act of releasing someone from the guilt or penalty of sin, highlighting the idea of forgiveness as letting go. κρατέω (krateō, “retain”): This word means to hold fast, keep, or retain. Here, it suggests holding onto sins, meaning not declaring them forgiven. The contrast with “remit” shows the seriousness of the responsibility Jesus gives. ἁμαρτία (hamartia, “sins”): This is the common Greek word for “sins,” meaning offenses or failures to meet God’s standard. The focus is on moral or spiritual wrongdoing, not just mistakes.

Question 3

Why John 20:23 matters

Accepted Answer

John 20:23 is sometimes misunderstood as giving unlimited personal authority to forgive or withhold forgiveness, but the context points to the disciples acting as messengers of God’s forgiveness, not as the source of it. The verse connects the authority to forgive with the giving of the Holy Spirit, showing that this responsibility is tied to God’s work through his people, not to human power alone. This moment is part of Jesus preparing his followers for their mission after his resurrection, highlighting the central role of forgiveness in the message they are to share.

John 20:23 (KJV)