And Moses' father in law said unto him, The thing that thou doest is not good.
EXODUS 18:17KJVWhat does Exodus 18:17 mean?
Exodus 18:17 records Moses’ father-in-law telling Moses that the way he is handling his responsibilities is not good. Jethro is pointing out a problem with how Moses is trying to judge and lead the people all by himself.
In this scene, Jethro (Moses’ father-in-law) is observing Moses as he listens to the disputes and needs of the entire Israelite community from morning until evening. Jethro sees that Moses is taking on too much alone and warns him that this approach is not wise or sustainable. This verse sets up Jethro’s advice for a better way to share leadership and lighten Moses’ burden.
The Hebrew behind Exodus 18:17
- "good" (טוֹב, tov): This word means “good,” “pleasant,” or “beneficial.” Here, Jethro is not just saying Moses’ method is inconvenient, but that it is not beneficial or right for Moses or the people.
- "thing" (דָּבָר, davar): This word means “matter,” “thing,” or “word.” Jethro is referring specifically to the way Moses is handling the situation, not just a single action.
Why Exodus 18:17 matters
- This verse clarifies that even a respected leader like Moses can benefit from outside advice and correction, especially from someone who cares about his well-being.
- It highlights the importance of sustainable leadership and the need to share responsibilities, which becomes a key theme in the following verses.
- Exodus 18:17 helps explain the origin of the system of judges and leaders among the Israelites, showing that it was prompted by practical wisdom and concern for both Moses and the people.