Question 1

What does Mark 9:28 mean?

Accepted Answer

Mark 9:28 describes how, after Jesus and his disciples entered a house, the disciples privately asked Jesus why they had been unable to cast out an unclean spirit from a boy. The verse shows the disciples seeking understanding from Jesus about their failure in a moment when they were alone with him. The setting is just after Jesus healed a boy whom his disciples could not help. The disciples wait until they are inside, away from the crowds, to question Jesus about why they could not perform the exorcism. This private conversation highlights their confusion and desire to learn more from Jesus about spiritual authority and power.

Question 2

The Greek behind Mark 9:28

Accepted Answer

The word "privately" comes from two Greek words: κατά (kata, "according to") and ἴδιος (idios, "one’s own" or "private"). Together, they stress that the disciples asked Jesus in a setting away from others, emphasizing the personal and confidential nature of their question. The Greek word ἐπηρώτων (epērōtōn, "asked") suggests more than a casual question; it often carries the sense of inquiring or seeking an explanation, showing the disciples’ genuine desire to understand.

Question 3

Why Mark 9:28 matters

Accepted Answer

Mark 9:28 clarifies that the disciples did not immediately understand why they failed, showing their humility and willingness to learn from Jesus rather than pretending to know the answer. The verse sets up Jesus’ following explanation, which addresses faith, prayer, and dependence on God, making this private question an important turning point in the story. This moment highlights the difference between public ministry and private teaching, showing that Jesus often explained deeper truths to his closest followers in a more intimate setting.

Mark 9:28 (KJV)