Question 1

What does Matthew 17:10 mean?

Accepted Answer

Matthew 17:10 shows the disciples asking Jesus why the religious experts (the scribes) say that Elijah (“Elias” in the KJV) must come before the Messiah appears. The disciples are confused about how Jesus fits into the prophecies they have learned, especially the teaching that Elijah would return first. In this scene, Jesus’ disciples are speaking directly to him after witnessing the Transfiguration, where Jesus appeared with Moses and Elijah. Their question reflects a common Jewish expectation based on Old Testament prophecy (especially Malachi 4:5) that Elijah would come before the Messiah. The verse highlights the disciples’ effort to understand how Jesus’ ministry relates to these long-held beliefs.

Question 2

The Greek behind Matthew 17:10

Accepted Answer

Ἠλίας (Ēlias): This is the Greek form of “Elijah,” the Old Testament prophet. The use of this name connects directly to Jewish prophetic expectations and shows the disciples are thinking about specific prophecies. δεῖ (dei): Translated here as “must,” this word carries a sense of necessity or something that is required. The disciples are asking about something they believe is a necessary step before the Messiah comes. πρῶτον (prōton): This means “first,” emphasizing the order of events the disciples expect—Elijah’s coming must happen before anything else.

Question 3

Why Matthew 17:10 matters

Accepted Answer

This verse reveals that the disciples are still trying to fit Jesus into their existing framework of prophecy, showing their honest confusion and desire to understand. It connects the New Testament story directly to Old Testament prophecy, especially the expectation from Malachi that Elijah would return. The question sets up Jesus’ explanation in the following verses, where he clarifies how John the Baptist fulfilled the role of Elijah, helping the reader see how prophecy and fulfillment work together in the Gospel narrative.

Matthew 17:10 (KJV)