Question 1

What does 2 Samuel 17:4 mean?

Accepted Answer

2 Samuel 17:4 describes how Absalom and all the elders of Israel were pleased with the advice that had just been given. The verse shows that the suggestion made to Absalom was well-received by both him and his advisors. In the story, Absalom is leading a rebellion against his father, King David. The advice mentioned comes from Ahithophel, one of Absalom’s counselors, who had just outlined a plan to pursue David. The verse highlights that not only Absalom but also the elders—Israel’s leaders—agreed with this plan, showing a moment of unity and approval among Absalom’s supporters.

Question 2

The Hebrew behind 2 Samuel 17:4

Accepted Answer

"saying" (דָּבָר, davar): This word often means "word," "matter," or "thing." Here, it refers to the specific advice or plan just given to Absalom. "pleased" (יָשַׁר, yashar): This verb means "to be right" or "to be pleasing." In this context, it shows that the advice seemed good or fitting in their eyes. "well" (עַיִן, ayin): Literally "eye," but often used in Hebrew to mean "in the opinion of" or "in the view of." The phrase means the advice was pleasing in their eyes, not just acceptable but genuinely favored. "elders" (זָקֵן, zaqen): Refers to the senior leaders or respected men of Israel. Their agreement signals broad support for the plan, not just a personal decision by Absalom.

Question 3

Why 2 Samuel 17:4 matters

Accepted Answer

This verse shows that Absalom was not acting alone—he had the backing of Israel’s elders, which gave his rebellion more legitimacy and strength. The approval of both Absalom and the elders sets up the tension in the story, as their unity contrasts with the divided loyalties in Israel during David’s flight. Understanding that the advice was "pleasing in their eyes" helps clarify that the decision was not forced or reluctant, but a genuine consensus, which makes the later turn of events more dramatic.

2 Samuel 17:4 (KJV)